Yes, doctors mourn too
But deep involvement is crucial to healing process
By Javeed Akhter
When Danielle's mom called that April afternoon, I knew I had to go.
I had promised myself that, as her physician and her friend, I would
go to her home when the end appeared inevitable.
The shadows were lengthening, but the sun was still bright when I
arrived. A few people were out lounging or tending to their gardens.
Kids were playing, their shouts and laughter punctuating the calm.
Her family was waiting for me and took me upstairs to Danielle's
bedroom. She lay in her bed breathing with obvious difficulty and,
because of her failing respiration, was unaware of her surroundings.
Her mother was by her side. Danielle was covered by a favorite
purple and white afghan and surrounded by her favorite trinkets,
books, pictures of family -- even her three Chihuahuas.
Danielle was just 22.
Although I have seen many of my patients die, the experience is
still searing. Early in my career I had tried to erect a firewall
between me and my patients. Emotional burnout is not uncommon among
caregivers dealing with serious and fatal illnesses. I remember
that, after the death of one patient, I was depressed for days. But
I came to realize how futile it was trying to distance myself from
I now believe it is, in fact, necessary to get deeply involved, to
get entangled in the roller coaster of emotions my patients and
their families are going through. It is part of trying to be a
healer, not just a technocrat physician. I have to be there to utter
the words of encouragement, to provide the shoulder to cry on, to
remind people that they are not alone in their sorrow.
Months earlier, Danielle and I had talked about the inevitable end.
After the last complication of her illness, when we used a catheter
to remove fluid from the lining of her lung, she decided she did not
want a needle stuck in her ever again.
Her cystic fibrosis was complicated by severe rheumatoid arthritis
that precluded the option of a lung transplant.
We agreed to deal with her illness at home with pain medications,
oxygen and other comfort measures. Danielle wanted to be active in
her job as long as she could and wished to die at home. She worked
until a day before her death.
When I had first met her, she was very quiet. Gradually, she came to
trust me and was comfortable enough to playfully insult me from time
to time, something she took great pleasure in. I still treasure the
small framed note she gave me once that said, "When I count my
blessings, I count you twice."
Danielle had endured her long and difficult illness with uncommon
class and had come to terms with it.
After a few minutes in her bedroom, I walked downstairs, where the
rest of the family was gathered in the kitchen. I gave them the
phone number where the funeral home could reach me so I could take
care of the death certificate. I said my goodbyes and walked out.
I stood leaning against my car for a few minutes. I gradually became
aware of the street. The kids appeared to be moving in slow motion,
the voices seemed distant. Everything looked slightly out of focus.
No one out in the street would have guessed Danielle was dying
Physician, family member
When someone is dying, I know I should be the strongest in the room.
But my eyes mist up, and I have to look away to regain control.
These experiences are rewarding because I feel I have provided a
tiny bit of solace and comfort. I feel humbled when families allow
me the deepest access into their lives and consider me a friend.
This was the case with William and his family. Only a few months
before he died at age 19, I had gone to William's house when he
invited me to his high school graduation party.
I was impressed at William's energy as he first played ice hockey
and later tennis in high school. He was excited that he had just
been accepted into a computer program at a downtown college.
When he learned I had arrived at his party he ran out to greet me
and gave me a hug. I noticed him looking around and asked what he
was looking for. He said, "Your car." I had my Toyota, and he was
looking for a Ferrari or Bentley. We had a good laugh. This was
before we discovered he had colon cancer.
When we realized that William had come down with cancer on top of
his cystic fibrosis, it seemed like an uncommonly cruel fate.
Predictably, he went through anger and depression. Initially he was
hopeful that he might be able to beat the cancer, but he later knew
the end was inevitable.
Although I gave him the opportunity, William never talked to me
about death directly. His parents told me, however, that he wanted
me to assure him that when the end came he would not feel as if he
Although William did not care whether his death came at home or at
the hospital, his parents did not want him to die at home. They
wanted home associated with positive memories. They felt his room
would be haunted with painful memories if he died there.
Nurses and physicians were attentive to William's and his family's
needs. William did not want to be left alone even for a moment and
was surrounded by his family to the end. We were able to give him
enough sedation and a breathing assist device that allowed him to
die in peace, without the feeling of suffocating that he so feared.
William's dad wanted to walk with his body to the morgue, and we
walked with him.
At William's wake, his dad introduced me as a family member.
I felt that roller coaster of emotions again when it came to the
death of my youngest sister, Parveen, 49.
For her, the decision to die at home was not a difficult one. When
she realized nothing more could be done for her colon cancer, she
wanted to go home to be close to her family. She had fought the
cancer with extraordinary fortitude but was now exhausted.
Even through her pain and fatigue she worried about her children
more than herself; nothing else seemed to matter.
At home her condition worsened quickly and I could see her slipping
away. During the last hours I could not tell if she was aware of her
surroundings. As our family kept vigil in her room, I kept thinking
of her simple life; the adjectives "selfless" and "noble" kept
coming to mind.
It felt so unfair that she could not buy a few more years to
celebrate the achievements of the children she loved so much. I felt
despondent, helpless and guilty that I was in good health and had
already lived years longer than she would.
As time seemed to pass ever so slowly in that room, I recalled a
verse from the Quran about the moment of death: "[God] is nearer to
him/her than you, but you cannot see." And I felt God was with her.
She, like Danielle and William, passed in peace surrounded by her
(Copyright 2007 by the Chicago Tribune)
Javeed Akhter is director of the cystic fibrosis program at Advocate
Hope Children's Hospital.
..:BACK TO ARTICLES & PUBLICATIONS:..