Table of Contents

Abbreviations Used in the Essay
Foreword: Dr. John O Voll
Editor's Note: Sabreen Akhter
Objectives of the Review
Attitudes towards Prophet Muhammad
I. The Seeker of Truth
II. The Recipient of the Mantle of Prophethood/ The Warner and the Exhorter
III. The Stoic Optimist
IV. The Pluralistic Leader
V. The Courageous Yet Reluctant Warrior
VI. The Statesman par excellence and the Teacher
VII. The Compassionate Ruler and Spiritual Leader
Does this essay cover any new ground?
The Sources for This Essay

Back to ISPI Home

Chapter I: The Search for Light in a Period of Darkness

The Seeker of Truth

The purpose of this article is not to review world history at the time of the advent of Islam, therefore my comments here are necessarily broad and sweeping in character. Nevertheless the Seventh century appears to have been a time of world wide moral confusion and decay. Christianity had divided into various sects and factions and controversies surrounded the personalities of Jesus and his mother, Mary. The Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches exhibited deep prejudice against each other and much intolerance. In Persia, absolutism of the monarchical system influenced and controlled most aspects of the society, and Zoroastrianism was unraveling. In addition to internal turmoil, Christianity and Zoroastrianism were in a constant state of friction. India and China were similarly morally adrift. India had thrown out Buddhism out of its birth land, and the old polytheistic practices were resurgent. The oppressive caste system, which Buddhism had revolted against, was as entrenched as ever. In China, a great flowering of the arts, music and dance was occurring, while at the same time there was general moral confusion. Many Chinese individuals claimed to be the followers of all of the three prevailing traditions, Confucianism, Taoism, and Buddhism. Buddha had been turned into an object of worship and huge statues depicting his likeness were commonplace; a surprising turn of events for a non-theistic religion whose founder had never claimed divinity, or prescribed idol worship.
The Arabian Peninsula, with the exception of Yemen, which was on the caravan route, was in darkness. Little was known about it to the outside world. Polytheism and idol worship were rampant in Arabia, so was tribalism and unrestrained pursuit of wealth and power. Most Arabs were nomads, with the tribal structure assuring them security. This stability was based largely on the tradition of "blood vengeance," which invariably resulted in an endless cycle of revenge. Society seemed even harsher in the cities. There were only a few cities like Makkah, Yathrib (later Madinat an-Nabi, city of the Prophet or for short Madinah), and Ta'if. A small number of rich and powerful families controlled the economy. Many of the poor were eternally entangled in a web of usury riba. This system of riba turned them into virtual slaves. Slavery itself was commonplace. Women's status was also extremely deplorable and they were treated largely as chattel, which was essentially another form of slavery. Marriage, inheritance, and divorce laws reflected the chauvinistic attitudes prevalent in the society. For example unlimited polygamy was widespread, primogeniture was the rule and sons often inherited their father's wives. A husband could stop conjugal relations with his wife and abdicate all responsibilities toward her without divorcing her and letting her go free. This cruel treatment of wives called zihar (turning your back on something) was widely practiced.
Although females were oppressed and abused routinely, female infanticide was commonplace, and male progeny was a source of pride and status in society, the majority of deities were female. The three major deities, al-Lat, al'-Uzza, and al-Manat were considered the daughters of Allah.
Have you seen al-Lat and al-Uzza and the third Manat?
What for you the male gender and for Him the female!
(Qur'an 53: 19-21.)
The Qur'an refers to the practice of burying alive infant girls by posing this poignant question;
When the female infant buried alive will ask for what crime was she killed? (Qur'an 81:8-9)

These injustices, inequities, and cruelties weighed heavily on the shoulders of at least some of the individuals living in Arabia. In spite of rampant polytheism and idol worship, some did have a concept of a transcendent God whom they called Allah.
The Qur'an refers to this in the following verses:
" If indeed thou ask them who has created the heavens the earth and subjected the sun and the moon (to His law), they will certainly reply, Allah. How are they then led away (from the truth)? Allah enlarges the sustenance (which He gives) to whichever of His servants He pleases; And if indeed thou ask them who it is that sends down rain from the sky, And gives life therewith to the earth after its death, they will certainly reply, Allah! But most of them understand not. What is the life of this world but amusement and play? But verily the home in the Hereafter - that is life indeed, if they but knew Now if they embark on a boat they call on Allah, making their devotion sincerely to Him. But when He has delivered them safely to land behold they give a share of their worship to others! ---". (Qur'an 29: 61-65)

Ibn Ishaq records that there were at least four individuals in Makkah who had turned away from idol worship and polytheism and had adopted the monotheism of Prophet Ibrahim (Abraham). They included the important figure, Waraqah bin Nawfal, who later verified the authenticity of Muhammad's (S) Prophethood. These people were called the Hanifs (the upright men or those who has turned away [from idol worship]).
Born in 570 C.E. Muhammad (S) was orphaned early in his life and was raised initially by a loving but poor grandfather Abd al-Muttalib and later by his Uncle Abu Talib. In these early years Muhammad (S) emerges as a quiet, thoughtful and introspective individual. He earned a reputation for being trustworthy (this earned him the title al-Amin), diplomatic and wise. There was an incident in his youth, during the rebuilding of the Ka'bah when a dispute arose over which tribe should place the "Black Stone" (al-Hajar al - Aswad) back in its previous spot. Muhammad (S) solved the problem by placing the stone on his cloak and asked members of all the tribes to lift it up. He then laid the stone in its designated spot himself.
He proved himself a conscientious and successful businessperson and caravan leader. This business acumen and his widely known reputation of trustworthiness thoughtfulness and gentility attracted the attention of Khadijah. An exceptional woman, Khadijah was a prominent businesswoman in a misogynist society. She had been married twice before and was a widow. Her marriage to Muhammad (S) was very fruitful and lasted until the rest of her life. They had six children, two sons 9who died as infants) and four daughters (Zayanb, Ruqayyah, Umm kulthum and Fatima).
Although married to a wealthy woman, the Prophet continued to lead a frugal life and spent much time in meditation. His favorite place for meditation was the Hira cave about three miles from Makkah. He would spend the entire month of Ramadan (the ninth month of the lunar calendar, and later the month during which Muslims were ordained to fast in order to practice abstinence and self-discipline to attain personal piety) meditating in this cave. This practice of meditating in seclusion, striving for wisdom and righteousness was common among the Arabs and was called "Tahannuf." The cave of Hira was where he received his initial revelation. However after he received the first revelation, which was in essence a call for action, the Prophet never went back to the cave.
It is difficult to resist drawing analogies between the seventh century world and the state of the human morality in today's world at the turn of the new millennium. The nuclear man-woman, two-parent family, as a core unit of society has eroded seriously in the West. Brazen sexual exploitation in the media is commonplace and illicit sex condoned and even accepted. Violence at home, against women, children, and violence in the streets, is frightfully routine. Substance abuse is widespread, with United States as the largest consumer of drugs in the world. Alcoholism is rampant, especially among college students, with only feeble attempts being made to address the problem. The lessons from the AIDS epidemic are being swept under the rug of political correctness. African- Americans have been liberated as slaves for a century and a half, yet many are still trapped in an unending cycle of poverty and discrimination, which is in a way a form of economic slavery. Because of a system that allows unrestrained growth of wealth without encouraging proper redistribution, economic disparities and injustices continue to grow at an alarming rate.
There are many excellent characteristics in Western societies, especially in the US, particularly freedom of thought, speech and assembly, a tolerant attitude toward eccentricities in human nature and an ambition to be a just and compassionate society. Many of these qualities, especially freedom of speech and thought and pluralism, are sadly lacking in many Muslim societies. Nevertheless the moral and socio- economic scene of today's world is uncannily similar to seventh century Arabia before the advent of Islam.
The unraveling of the moral fabric in today's society must weigh heavily on the minds of individuals with insight. They can draw personal solace and inspiration from the Prophet's life. The Arab tribal society of the Seventh century, whose structure was based on greed, debauchery, and violence, was changed in a very short time, by the Prophet, into a society with one of the highest moral standards in history. Compassion, humility, devotion to God and egalitarianism replaced the old well-entrenched tribal attitudes of pride in wealth, family and class, cruelty toward fellow humans and self-centered behavior. Women, for the first time in history, had rights and dignity, and the vulnerable and weak sections of the society were protected. Sexuality was removed from public prurience and became private and wholesome. Wealth was re-circulated so that even the smallest capillaries of the society were infused with energy and indigence became nearly extinct.
Those who are receptive to learning from Muhammad's (S) mission can draw inspiration and hope to reform the society they are living in. Their biggest challenge, however, would be to grasp the core values of his message by removing the accretions of cultural practices, vagaries of time and historical events that have confounded it. They cannot turn to any of the modern Muslim nations to search for paradigms of Muhammad's (S) community during his life. In fact in many Muslim countries and communities, anthropologists and social scientists discern the perplexing paradox of rapidly increasing enthusiasm for Islam and respect for Muhammad (S), and the persistence of very high levels of corruption, tribalism, violence, intolerance and injustice, which are the antithesis of the very ideals he preached and practiced in his life.
If the thoughtful analyst is successful in this attempt at understanding the core values of the Prophet's message, then he is likely to come up with dynamic and innovative solutions to current and future problems. The approach by most Muslims at solving current problems has been imitative rather than innovative. The lessons the analyst obtains are likely to have universal value and applicability, as human needs and problems are essentially the same regardless of color, ethnicity, race or religion or the century or millennium in which the person is living.